John Fenton Nightingale is Jack Fenton's ancestor from Salem, Massachusetts, in the 1600s.
Like many other residents of Salem in the 1600s, John Fenton Nightingale believes in witches, and he himself is a witch-hunter and even claims to be "Salem's Greatest Witch-Whacker." Among witches, he also hunts ghosts, just like his descendants do. It is unknown how many witch- and ghost-hunting weapons he possesses, but he is known to have at least one: Blood Blossoms.
In "Infinite Realms," when Danny, Tucker, Sam and Vlad get transported to Massachusetts in the 1600s by the Infi-map, he appears among the mob surrounding Sam, tied up after being accused of witchcraft. He lays a ring of Blood Blossoms around Sam, and then puts a few blossoms in a sandwich, proving that they are edible.
He looks like Jack Fenton, but with longer hair. He wears a long orange overcoat, on top of the traditional clothes seen on the other residents of Salem. He also wears black gloves, and has a pocket watch with a gold chain.
- 302. "Infinite Realms"